backstageadd ND

St. Joseph City Leaders Listen to their Constituents

St. Joseph City Leaders Listen to their Constituents

Postby Happy Mom » Tue Sep 13, 2011 4:02 pm

FACT FINDER: Venetian Festival's future in limbo
Community survey yields negeative feedback; City officials cut funding

By Colleen Ferreira (

12:57 a.m. EDT, September 13, 2011
ST. JOSEPH, Mich. —
Survey results are in and changes are coming.

The City of St. Joseph will stop financial support toward two of its five summer festivals starting next year ... including the Venetian Festival. The other loser is the city's Labor Day fireworks show.

In August, the city sent out nearly 6,000 surveys to businesses and registered voters asking them which festivals they supported and which ones were not high on their favorites' list. Just over 2,000 surveys were answered.

City Manager Frank Walsh released survey results at a city commissioner meeting on Monday evening.


Respondents were asked their interest level in the city's five biggest summer events: Blossomtime Parade, Krasal Art Fair, 4th of July fireworks, Venetian Festival and Labor Day fireworks.

67.8 percent of respondents the city shouldn't continue funding the Venetian Fest; "Three out of 4 businesses were not in favor of the Venetian Festival," Walsh said.

60 percent said the city shouldn't pay for Labor Day fireworks.

CON: Some people who live and work in St. Joseph said a few festivals are more of a hindrance than benefit to the city. "When 70 percent of taxpayers tell you something, you ought to listen," Walsh said.

Vitale's Subs was one of those businesses. "I remember when Venetian was a taste of southwest Michigan and it had all the local restaurants and now there's no local feel down here, all outside vendors," said Olivia Megna from Vitale’s Subs.

PRO: "Business has been great, absolutely great," said store owner Judy Benninghoff. Summer customers are keeping her business going. "We did a projection for what we needed to do for the first six months and we've more than met that," Benninghoff said. She attributes much of her business success to the city's summer festivals.

Cost factors ...

It costs the city $21,000 to put on the Labor Day fireworks show. The city gives $23,000 through in-kind services to the Venetian Festival. Those in-kind services include police and fire coverage.

So what now?

The city is willing to work with festival organizers and reconsider funding IF the festival is revamped to be more family friendly.
WSBT asked Walsh if he is worried the festival could leave St. Joe all together? “I'm not worried, that would be up to the festival organizers," Walsh said.

City officials will seek an outside source to fund the fireworks.

Festival leader says ...

Lori Draper, Venetian Festival president, said the organization doesn't yet know the festival future in St. Joseph.

As of Monday night, she said it could move to another city or they might stop the festival all together. Still, she said, organizers are willing to work with the city to develop a restructured festival format so the city could reconsider funding.

Draper said festival leaders are disappointed, but they anticipated negative survey results, saying many people believe Venetian Fest has become a big burden on the community because of the crowds. Downtown parking is limited, so festival organizers offered free shuttles from several remote parking lots.

The four-day event on the waterfront in downtown St. Joseph celebrated its 33rd year in 2011. Festival area includes Lake Bluff Park atop the bluff to Silver Beach and the St. Joseph River. ... 5953.story
"Preserving and protecting the principles of the Constitution is the primary role of the federal government."
User avatar
Happy Mom
Posts: 19481
Joined: Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:03 am
Location: Granger

Re: St. Joseph City Leaders Listen to their Constituents

Postby Dr. Nick » Wed Sep 14, 2011 4:03 pm

I have been to the Venetian and it is a monstrosity. I am sure that it was a pleasant community festival in the past but it has grown into a behemoth and, with that (unfortunately), has come the downside of a large festival: shady vendors and shadier people.
This message has not been approved or paid for by Butch Morgan or the Democratic Machine.
User avatar
Dr. Nick
Posts: 209
Joined: Mon Oct 11, 2010 4:06 pm
Location: Osceola

Re: St. Joseph City Leaders Listen to their Constituents

Postby Happy Mom » Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:11 am

End of an era: Venetian Festival canceled

8:03 p.m. EDT, September 27, 2011

ST. JOSEPH – After 33 years, the Venetian Festival board has made the tough decision to end it for good.

After years of ups and downs with attendance and revenues, 2011 turned about to be a good year for the Venetian Festival. Festival board members had a feeling of enthusiasm and hope. Now, months later, the feeling is something else -- disappointment.

"Shock and disappointment," said Lori Draper, Venetian Festival president.

For years, St. Joseph and the Venetian fest went hand in hand. Not anymore.

"A lot of people had the opinion it didn't have the local appeal anymore," said Diana Koehler. "A lot of the local people stayed away.

But each year, the festival was a huge draw.

"People were coming and coming and coming," said Draper.

That may have been the problem for St. Joseph residents.
"They weren't really happy about so many people coming to town and crowding their city," said Draper.

They also weren't happy about the disruptions or the number of streets blocked off.

"The area has changed and access to the areas is more critical," said Police Chief Marc Clapp.

Especially around the relatively new Whirlpool Fountain and Carousel. People were fed up with the road closures and delays.

Draper said the results in the festival survey did the Venetian Festival in. Two out of three people surveyed said they avoid it and tax dollars shouldn't fund it. The city followed through. :clap: :clap: :clap:

There were also negative comments from merchants in the survey. They said they didn't make money.

"All the outside vendors are brought in for food, where the rides are, people, the beach," said Olivia Megna, who owns Vitale's Famous Subs in downtown St. Joseph. "Nine times out of 10, people don't come up to the bluff to eat."

Draper said the festival could have moved to another city or scaled down to continue on. In the end, there were too many questions:

"At the end of the day, it was too big of a risk," she said. "We couldn't make it work under the constraints issued."

"We didn't have a choice but to retire the festival," said Draper.

Draper stopped short of saying the festival was driven out by some of the merchants and the older population, but she said it was evident: the festival attendees did not fit in.

"We are a rock festival, and we attract people of all demographics – white collar, blue collar workers, all kinds of people," Draper said. "Not everybody who comes to our festival fits in to the downtown picture.
Statement from the President of the Venetian Festival
"After much deliberation, the Senior Membership of the Venetian Festival made the difficult decision last night to retire this iconic event that has been a summer destination in the City of St. Joseph for 33 years. The decision came only after exhaustive discussion of any reasonable means of redesigning the festival to fit the parameters set forth by the city during a meeting with city officials last week.

"While city officials offered to listen to a new plan for the festival, they were direct in that they were inflexible on certain constraints, and festival organizers felt there was indifference toward working cooperatively to retain the event in the city.

"Following that meeting, festival organizers studied a variety of concepts for redesigning the festival to work within the city's parameters including, as many have often suggested, "returning to its roots" of a smaller festival confined to the arboretum. However, the passing of years that, among other things, resulted in significant growth of trees in the original arboretum location, the need to update the infrastructure to support the event, public safety issues, and skyrocketing costs of entertainment, made that option neither viable logistically or advisable financially for the organization.
"Consequently, after much hopeful discussion of continuing on, the membership came to the sad conclusion that the Venetian Festival no longer had a home in the city of St. Joseph, and elected to retire the event.

"For festival organizers, it has truly been an honor and a privilege to present this festival to southwestern Michigan for the past 33 years. The Venetian Festival has been a labor of love for all of us involved, and we are deeply saddened to see the festival come to this end. But we hope that you - our friends and fans - will continue to cherish the memories of spending the third weekend of every July at the Venetian Festival, and we thank you for the wonderful memories you have created for us, as well." ... 4587.story
"Preserving and protecting the principles of the Constitution is the primary role of the federal government."
User avatar
Happy Mom
Posts: 19481
Joined: Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:03 am
Location: Granger

Return to Indiana and Midwest

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest